Ask Amma

Yogurt in Winter – Tips for keeping it warm

In How on 24 January 2019 at 7:25 pm

To make yogurt, you need yogurt.  What if you have no yogurt? Ask your neighbor. Like a candle can light another without losing its own flame, fermentation too is a neighborly process.

“How did they make the first yogurt?” my daughter once asked me. That, I replied, was like asking “who was the first neighbor?”

You also need a warm place. What if it is cold?? Here we will give not a philosophical but a practical answer.

Warmth is the key to perfectly set yogurt every time!

First, in case you are new to making yogurt, here are the simple steps to make yogurt at home.

  1. Heat milk slowly till layer forms. For 1/2 gallon of milk I usually heat on low or medium low (3 or 4 on a scale of 1-9) for 30-40 minutes. (I keep wondering if I really need to heat it that long but I have not experimented with shorter heating times.)
  2. Allow to cool until it is still quite warm but not too hot. Test the temperature with your finger. It should be very warm, but not uncomfortably hot.
  3. Add yogurt. Use the more liquidy part – the whey. I usually add 2-3 spoons. I find this varies regionally. In India I could get away with only half a spoon but in the US I find it better to err on the side of too much. Even up to 1/4 cup is okay, though usually not necessary.
  4. Keep in a warm place. Think of India in the summer. Or Arizona with some humidity added. If all conditions are right, the yogurt will set in 4 hours. If more than 8 hours have passed and it still has not set you can try to rescue it by putting it into warmer surroundings. The sooner it sets the milder its flavor is. If you like it tart you can leave it longer but eventually you should put it in the fridge. It will gradually sour with each passing day, but much less than it would at room temperature.

Now to the question: where do you get such a warm place if you are in a cold climate? People have come up with all kinds of techniques for keeping the pot of warm milk warm long enough for it to transform into yogurt. Some keep it near the radiator or heating vents, some keep it in the oven with the pilot light on. I used to turn the oven on for 1 minute, then turn it off, sometimes putting a pot of warm water in the oven to add humidity. Some buy pots that can be set to a constant temperature of 110 degrees. While this is an ideal temperature, it uses electricity for hours. In this day and age, who wants that?

Imagine my delight when I discovered a way to maintain that warm nourishing temperature without using any electricity or gas. Since the milk is already at the right temperature at the time you add the yogurt to make more yogurt, all you really need to do is maintain that warmth. You need to insulate that pot. For this you can use:

  1. A haybox – bamboo box lined with hay that is sewn in place using jute.
  2. A snug cloth case insulated with another natural fiber such as
    బీరకాయ పీచు  – ridge gourd fiber.
  3. Any insulated bag, supplemented with cloth or packing material to keep contents warm.

Look at this yogurt I made in January when the temperature in Maryland was in single digits – way below freezing!

Warmth is the key to perfectly set yogurt every time!

So there you have it! Even when it is cold you can make luscious yogurt. You’re welcome 🙂

  1. I love making my own yogurt.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: